Skip to main content
eBay Home

Shop by category

Advanced
    • Daily Deals
    • Help & Contact
    • Sell
    • My eBayExpand My eBay
      • Summary
      • Recently Viewed
      • Bids/Offers
      • Watch List
      • Purchase History
      • Selling
      • Saved Searches
      • Saved Sellers
      • Messages
    {"delay":300}

    There seems to be a problem serving the request at this time

    breadcrumb

    • eBay
      • Collectibles & Art
      • Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop
    • Collectibles & Art
    • Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop
    • Autographs-Original
    • Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA) Gary Carter Original Sports Autographed Items

    Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA) Gary Carter Original Sports Autographed Items

    Side Refine Panel

    Shop by Category

    • Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop
    • Autographs-Original
    • Baseball-MLB
    • Basketball-NBA
    • Basketball-WNBA
    • Boxing
    • College-NCAA
    • Display Cases
    • Football-NFL
    • Golf-LPGA
    • Golf-PGA
    • Golf-Other
    • Hockey-NHL
    • Hockey-Other
    • Mixed Martial Arts (MMA)
    • Olympics
    • Racing-Formula 1
    • Racing-NASCAR
    • Racing-NHRA
    • Racing-Other
    • Rugby
    • Soccer
      • Tennis
      • Wrestling
      • Other Autographed Sports Mem
    • All

    • Auction

    • Buy It Now

    • Best Match
    • Time: Ending soonest
    • Time: Newly listed
    • Price + Postage: lowest first
    • Price + Postage: highest first
    • Distance: nearest first
    • Gallery View

    46 Results

      • Autograph Authentication: Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA) filter applied
      • Player: Gary Carter filter applied
      Clear All
      • Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA) filter applied
      • Gary Carter filter applied
      • All Listings filter applied
    • GARY CARTER Signed Book A Dream Season Signed God Bless Auto JSA/COA Ev Ticket

      GARY CARTER Signed Book A Dream Season Signed God Bless Auto JSA/COA Ev Ticket

      PHP 11,359.12
      PHP 2,185.49 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • GARY CARTER signed/autographed Rawlings MLB Major League Baseball w/HOF 2003-PSA

      GARY CARTER signed/autographed Rawlings MLB Major League Baseball w/HOF 2003-PSA

      PHP 31,234.74
      PHP 3,805.87 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • Gary Carter Signed Custom Expos Baseball Card PSA/DNA COA Autograph Hall of Fame

      Gary Carter Signed Custom Expos Baseball Card PSA/DNA COA Autograph Hall of Fame

      PHP 3,407.17
      PHP 1,811.78 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • Gary Edmund Carter Signed Hall of Fame Plaque Postcard (PSA/DNA) Mets / Expos

      Gary Edmund Carter Signed Hall of Fame Plaque Postcard (PSA/DNA) Mets / Expos

      PHP 8,516.50
      PHP 3,195.32 shipping
      SPONSORED
    • Gary Carter Expos Mets Signed " HOF 2003 " OMLB Baseball PSA/DNA AUTO COA

      New ListingGary Carter Expos Mets Signed " HOF 2003 " OMLB Baseball PSA/DNA AUTO COA

      PHP 17,038.11
      PHP 3,574.71 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Gary Carter "HOF 2003" Autographed Baseball PSA Graded GEM MINT 10

      Gary Carter "HOF 2003" Autographed Baseball PSA Graded GEM MINT 10

      PHP 11,302.32
      PHP 3,433.86 shipping
    • 1979 Topps #510 GARY CARTER Signed Autographed PSA/DNA Slabbed HOF

      1979 Topps #510 GARY CARTER Signed Autographed PSA/DNA Slabbed HOF

      PHP 4,259.67
      PHP 954.17 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • 1981 Donruss #90 GARY CARTER Signed Autographed PSA/DNA Slabbed HOF

      1981 Donruss #90 GARY CARTER Signed Autographed PSA/DNA Slabbed HOF

      PHP 4,259.67
      PHP 954.17 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • GARY CARTER  SIGNED OBNL BASEBALL SWEET SPOT PSA AN 15072 HALL OF FAMER

      GARY CARTER SIGNED OBNL BASEBALL SWEET SPOT PSA AN 15072 HALL OF FAMER

      PHP 8,518.77
      PHP 3,283.35 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Gary Carter Signed Gold HOF Plaque Postcard Yellow MTL Expos Autograph PSA/DNA

      Gary Carter Signed Gold HOF Plaque Postcard Yellow MTL Expos Autograph PSA/DNA

      PHP 5,111.04
      PHP 1,824.84 shipping
      2 watching
    • GARY CARTER PSA/DNA 10! Signed/Autographed Baseball SEALED!

      GARY CARTER PSA/DNA 10! Signed/Autographed Baseball SEALED!

      PHP 17,890.61
      PHP 3,566.76 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Gary Carter Eric Davis Mets Reds Signed Autograph 8 x 10 Photo PSA DNA

      Gary Carter Eric Davis Mets Reds Signed Autograph 8 x 10 Photo PSA DNA

      PHP 4,259.10
      PHP 1,548.82 shipping
    • 1975 MONTREAL EXPOS GARY CARTER MAUCH ROGERS 30 SIGNED AUTOGRAPH MLB BALL PSA

      1975 MONTREAL EXPOS GARY CARTER MAUCH ROGERS 30 SIGNED AUTOGRAPH MLB BALL PSA

      PHP 27,205.09
      PHP 3,255.52 shipping
    • Gary Carter signed Montreal Expos 1981 Sports Illustrated Magazine PSA/DNA 91545

      Gary Carter signed Montreal Expos 1981 Sports Illustrated Magazine PSA/DNA 91545

      PHP 3,903.56
      Was: PHP 4,486.85
      PHP 1,824.27 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • Gary Carter Signed 1981 Sports Illustrated Autographed Expos PSA/DNA AI11023

      Gary Carter Signed 1981 Sports Illustrated Autographed Expos PSA/DNA AI11023

      PHP 4,444.82
      Was: PHP 5,108.76
      PHP 1,553.36 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • Gary Carter signed Montreal Expos 1980 Sports Illustrated Magazine PSA/DNA

      Gary Carter signed Montreal Expos 1980 Sports Illustrated Magazine PSA/DNA

      PHP 5,385.93
      Was: PHP 6,190.72
      PHP 1,860.62 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • GARY CARTER Signed Book A Dream Season w script NEW YORK METS JSA COA

      GARY CARTER Signed Book A Dream Season w script NEW YORK METS JSA COA

      PHP 10,220.37
      PHP 3,061.85 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Rare GARY CARTER Signed Postcard-HALL OF FAME-NEW YORK METS-JSA PSA

      Rare GARY CARTER Signed Postcard-HALL OF FAME-NEW YORK METS-JSA PSA

      PHP 4,259.10
      Was: PHP 5,678.99
      PHP 1,889.59 shipping
    • Gary Carter Signed Baseball Autograph Auto PSA/DNA Rare Giamatti OMLB Baseball

      Gary Carter Signed Baseball Autograph Auto PSA/DNA Rare Giamatti OMLB Baseball

      PHP 11,358.55
      PHP 3,319.13 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Gary Carter Signed Postcard Autograph 1986 NY Mets Baseball HOF WSC Kid PSA/DNA

      Gary Carter Signed Postcard Autograph 1986 NY Mets Baseball HOF WSC Kid PSA/DNA

      PHP 4,259.10
      PHP 1,803.83 shipping
    • Gary Carter Signed Postcard Autograph 1986 NY Mets Baseball HOF WSC MLB PSA/DNA

      Gary Carter Signed Postcard Autograph 1986 NY Mets Baseball HOF WSC MLB PSA/DNA

      PHP 4,259.10
      PHP 1,803.83 shipping
    • Gary Carter NY Mets PSA/DNA signed 16x20 autograph Multiple Inscriptions The Kid

      Gary Carter NY Mets PSA/DNA signed 16x20 autograph Multiple Inscriptions The Kid

      PHP 22,715.40
      PHP 2,708.01 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • GARY CARTER Signed Official MLB Baseball-HALL OF FAME-NEW YORK METS-PSA

      GARY CARTER Signed Official MLB Baseball-HALL OF FAME-NEW YORK METS-PSA

      PHP 8,518.77
      Was: PHP 11,358.55
      PHP 3,138.52 shipping
    • Gary Carter Signed 1982 Fleer #638 Card Dave Parker Expos Autograph HOF PSA/DNA

      Gary Carter Signed 1982 Fleer #638 Card Dave Parker Expos Autograph HOF PSA/DNA

      PHP 7,950.82
      PHP 1,865.74 shipping
    • Gary Carter Signed Check PSA ENCAPSULATED NEW YORK Mets MONTREAL Expos Catcher

      Gary Carter Signed Check PSA ENCAPSULATED NEW YORK Mets MONTREAL Expos Catcher

      PHP 6,245.81
      PHP 1,597.66 shipping
    • Gary Carter signed New York Mets  1986 Sports Illustrated Magazine PSA/DNA 91544

      Gary Carter signed New York Mets 1986 Sports Illustrated Magazine PSA/DNA 91544

      PHP 5,395.58
      PHP 1,860.62 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Gary Carter Signed 8x10 Photo New York Mets Vintage 1986 Autograph PSA COA HOF

      Gary Carter Signed 8x10 Photo New York Mets Vintage 1986 Autograph PSA COA HOF

      PHP 5,678.99
      PHP 1,867.44 shipping
    • Signed New York Mets Gary Carter H.O.F. 8 X 10 Photo Matted & Framed PSA#

      Signed New York Mets Gary Carter H.O.F. 8 X 10 Photo Matted & Framed PSA#

      PHP 4,543.65
      PHP 4,349.97 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Gary Carter Signed 1983 Sports Illustrated Autographed Expos PSA/DNA AI11025

      Gary Carter Signed 1983 Sports Illustrated Autographed Expos PSA/DNA AI11025

      PHP 5,392.74
      PHP 1,576.65 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • 1983 All Star Game Team Signed Gary Carter Personal Game Issued Bat PSA DNA COA

      1983 All Star Game Team Signed Gary Carter Personal Game Issued Bat PSA DNA COA

      PHP 67,870.73
      PHP 1,703.87 shipping
      SPONSORED
    • Gary Carter Autograph 8x10 Photo "The Kid" Member of the 300 Homerun Club Marlin

      Gary Carter Autograph 8x10 Photo "The Kid" Member of the 300 Homerun Club Marlin

      PHP 2,839.21
      PHP 2,184.36 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • 1980 DIMANCHE SIGNED AUTO PHOTO GARY CARTER MONTREAL EXPOS METS DODGERS PSA DNA

      1980 DIMANCHE SIGNED AUTO PHOTO GARY CARTER MONTREAL EXPOS METS DODGERS PSA DNA

      PHP 5,678.99
      0 bids
      PHP 1,135.91 shipping
      Ending Wednesday at 1:57AM PHT2d 13h
    • Gary Carter Signed Postcard Autograph 1986 NY Mets Baseball HOF MLB Kid PSA/DNA

      Gary Carter Signed Postcard Autograph 1986 NY Mets Baseball HOF MLB Kid PSA/DNA

      PHP 4,259.10
      PHP 1,803.83 shipping
    • Gary Carter Signed 1982 Donruss Diamond King #2 Baseball Card HOF Auto PSA/DNA

      Gary Carter Signed 1982 Donruss Diamond King #2 Baseball Card HOF Auto PSA/DNA

      PHP 3,407.17
      PHP 1,754.42 shipping
    • Gary Carter & Doc Gooden Ny Mets 1986 Signed 8x10 Photo Framed Mint Auto HOF PSA

      Gary Carter & Doc Gooden Ny Mets 1986 Signed 8x10 Photo Framed Mint Auto HOF PSA

      PHP 17,038.11
      PHP 5,422.84 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • 1986 Ny Mets Team Signed Official World Series Baseball Gary Carter 11 Auto Psa

      1986 Ny Mets Team Signed Official World Series Baseball Gary Carter 11 Auto Psa

      PHP 42,596.13
      PHP 4,143.24 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Gary Carter Steve Howe Autograph Signed 8 X 10 Photo PSA/DNA Dodgers Expos

      Gary Carter Steve Howe Autograph Signed 8 X 10 Photo PSA/DNA Dodgers Expos

      PHP 7,666.84
      PHP 1,632.31 shipping
    • 1985 Mets Postcard GARY CARTER Autograph PSA-DNA Auto HOF | "Matt, God Bless,"

      1985 Mets Postcard GARY CARTER Autograph PSA-DNA Auto HOF | "Matt, God Bless,"

      PHP 3,691.15
      PHP 1,818.59 shipping
    • Gary Carter Signed FDC Envelope Nov 19 1983 Mets Expos Auto HOF PSA/DNA Mint 9

      Gary Carter Signed FDC Envelope Nov 19 1983 Mets Expos Auto HOF PSA/DNA Mint 9

      PHP 5,678.99
      PHP 1,838.47 shipping
    • Gary Carter (died 2012) HOF 2003 PSA/DNA Authentic Signed Baseball New York Mets

      Gary Carter (died 2012) HOF 2003 PSA/DNA Authentic Signed Baseball New York Mets

      PHP 21,581.76
      PHP 3,683.19 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Gary Carter Signed New York Post Paper 10/29/86 Mets WSC Parade Auto HOF PSA/DNA

      Gary Carter Signed New York Post Paper 10/29/86 Mets WSC Parade Auto HOF PSA/DNA

      PHP 8,518.77
      PHP 1,936.73 shipping
    • Gary Carter Signed Index Card Baseball Mets Montreal Expos HOF Autograph PSA/DNA

      Gary Carter Signed Index Card Baseball Mets Montreal Expos HOF Autograph PSA/DNA

      PHP 3,691.15
      PHP 1,790.20 shipping
    • Gary Carter Signed Index Card Baseball Expos NY Mets HOF PSA/DNA Auto Mint 9

      Gary Carter Signed Index Card Baseball Expos NY Mets HOF PSA/DNA Auto Mint 9

      PHP 5,678.99
      PHP 1,838.47 shipping
    • Gary Carter Signed Vintage Expos 8x10 Photo PSA AUTOGRAPHED HOF METS Deceased

      Gary Carter Signed Vintage Expos 8x10 Photo PSA AUTOGRAPHED HOF METS Deceased

      PHP 3,407.17
      PHP 1,924.80 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Gary Carter Autographed 1986 Sports Illustrated Mets World Series Cover PSA/DNA

      Gary Carter Autographed 1986 Sports Illustrated Mets World Series Cover PSA/DNA

      PHP 8,519.34
      PHP 7,341.40 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Gary Carter Roger McDowell Autograph Signed 8 X 10 Photo PSA/DNA New York Mets

      Gary Carter Roger McDowell Autograph Signed 8 X 10 Photo PSA/DNA New York Mets

      PHP 5,678.99
      PHP 1,583.46 shipping
    • Gary Carter Signed 1983 Donruss Action All Star #58 Baseball Card Auto PSA/DNA

      Gary Carter Signed 1983 Donruss Action All Star #58 Baseball Card Auto PSA/DNA

      PHP 3,975.12
      PHP 1,768.61 shipping
    • GARY CARTER HAND SIGNED NEW YORK METS COLOR 8 X 10 PHOTO PSA/DNA

      GARY CARTER HAND SIGNED NEW YORK METS COLOR 8 X 10 PHOTO PSA/DNA

      PHP 5,678.99
      PHP 2,131.54 shipping
      or Best Offer

    Additional site navigation

    • About eBay
    • Community
    • Policies
    • Help & Contact
    • Site Map
    Copyright © 1995-2023 eBay Inc. All Rights Reserved. User Agreement, Privacy, Payments Terms of Use, Cookies and AdChoice